Matter
Acqua nova v D... Z..., Lalla Y... Z... and Corse Multi Travaux Nicolai (French Court of Cassation, X 16-21.037)
- 30 July 2014France
30 July 2014France
Judgment of the Bastia Court of Appeal, Civil Chamber B, dated 30 July 2014
Bastia Court of Appeal, Civil Chamber B
- Decision summary
- The Bastia Court of Appeal confirmed Acqua nova's obligation to pay Corse Multi Travaux Nicolai €27,000 for the unpaid subcontractor invoice. It held the French courts territorially incompetent over Acqua nova's forced intervention against D... Z... and Lalla Y... Z..., treating those claims as an international dispute insufficiently connected with the original action; the defendants' mixed counterclaim was to follow the principal claim.
Supporting details
2 authorities · 4 participantsAcqua nova
D... Z...
Lalla Y... Z...
Corse Multi Travaux Nicolai
Bastia Court of Appeal, Civil Chamber B
3 years, 1 month and 8 days later · 1135 days
- 7 September 2017France
7 September 2017France
Decision of the Court of Cassation, Second Civil Chamber, in the case X 16-21.037 dated 7 September 2017
Court of Cassation, Second Civil Chamber
- Citation
- Decision No. 10588 F
- Decision summary
- The Court of Cassation rejected Acqua nova's appeal from the Bastia Court of Appeal's decision concerning the unpaid €27,000 subcontractor invoice and Acqua nova's claims against D... Z... and Lalla Y... Z.... It held that the ground of cassation was not manifestly capable of leading to quashing, ordered Acqua nova to pay the costs, rejected its claim under Article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, and ordered it to pay the Z. defendants €3,000 under that provision.
Supporting details
5 authorities · 11 participantsAcqua nova
- Representative
- SCP Fabiani, Luc-Thaler et Pinatel (For: Acqua nova)
D... Z...
- Representative
- SCP Bénabent et Jéhannin (For: D... Z... · Lalla Y... Z...)
Lalla Y... Z...
- Representative
- SCP Bénabent et Jéhannin (For: D... Z... · Lalla Y... Z...)
Corse Multi Travaux Nicolai
Court of Cassation, Second Civil Chamber
Other
- Institutional administrator
- Parchemal
- Date not availableFrance
Date not availableFrance
Judgment of the Ajaccio Commercial Court in the Acqua nova dispute
Ajaccio Commercial Court
- Decision summary
- The Ajaccio Commercial Court condemned Acqua nova to pay Corse Multi Travaux Nicolai €27,000 for the unpaid invoice for its subcontracted supply and installation of joinery and electric roller shutters on the construction project.
Supporting details
2 participantsAcqua nova
Corse Multi Travaux Nicolai
Ajaccio Commercial Court