Arbitral Digest

Matter

ADRU 75 v MMA IARD (French Court of Cassation, pourvoi R 21-14.542)

  1. 11 December 2014France

    11 December 2014France

    Second urgent application before the Paris Administrative Court dated 11 December 2014

    Paris Administrative Court

    Decision summary
    The Paris Administrative Court declared ADRU 75's second urgent application inadmissible because the contracts had already been signed on 17 October 2014 and the application challenged a preliminary act.

    Supporting details

    2 participants
    L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75)
    Representative
    M. [R] (For: L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75))
    Paris Administrative Court

    5 months and 7 days later · 158 days

  2. 18 May 2015France

    18 May 2015France

    Judgment of the Paris Administrative Court dated 18 May 2015 on the application to annul the decision of 24 September 2014

    Paris Administrative Court

    Decision summary
    The Paris Administrative Court held that ADRU 75's application had no object: the 24 September 2014 decision was a preliminary act detachable from the contracts signed on 17 October 2014 and was not open to an annulment action for excess of power.

    Supporting details

    2 participants
    L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75)
    Representative
    M. [R] (For: L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75))
    Paris Administrative Court

    5 years, 6 months and 13 days later · 2024 days

  3. 1 December 2020France

    1 December 2020France

    Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal, Division 2, Chamber 1, dated 1 December 2020

    Paris Court of Appeal, Division 2, Chamber 1

    Decision summary
    The Paris Court of Appeal dismissed ADRU 75's damages claims against MMA IARD arising from alleged procedural failures by its lawyer in challenging the withdrawal of the public-contract lots.

    Supporting details

    3 participants
    L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75)
    MMA IARD
    MMA IARD assurances mutuelles
    Paris Court of Appeal, Division 2, Chamber 1

    1 year, 9 months and 13 days later · 652 days

  4. 14 September 2022France

    14 September 2022France

    Judgment of the French Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, dated 14 September 2022 in pourvoi R 21-14.542

    French Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber

    Case no.
    R 21-14.542
    Citation
    Arrêt no 641 F-D
    Decision summary
    The Court of Cassation rejected ADRU 75's appeal against the Paris Court of Appeal judgment. It held that AP-HP was entitled to require the missing tax and social documents, so ADRU 75 had lost no chance of succeeding in a pre-contractual urgent application or a subsequent full-jurisdiction challenge; it ordered ADRU 75 to pay costs and rejected the article 700 claims.

    Supporting details

    4 authorities · 10 participants
    L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75)
    Representative
    Mme [V] [H] (For: L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75))
    Representative
    SARL Le Prado - Gilbert (For: L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75))
    MMA IARD
    Representative
    SARL Boré, Salve de Bruneton et Mégret (For: MMA IARD · MMA IARD assurances mutuelles)
    MMA IARD assurances mutuelles
    Representative
    SARL Boré, Salve de Bruneton et Mégret (For: MMA IARD · MMA IARD assurances mutuelles)
    French Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber
    Other
    Court Reporter
    Mme Tinchon

    Authorities cited

    4
    • French Public Procurement Code
      statute
    • French Decree No. 2008-1334 of 17 December 2008
      statute
    • French Civil Code
      statute
    • French Code of Civil Procedure
      statute
  5. Date not availableFrance

    Date not availableFrance

    First urgent application before the Paris Administrative Court

    Paris Administrative Court

    Decision summary
    The Paris Administrative Court declared ADRU 75's first urgent application challenging the withdrawal of its public-contract lots inadmissible.

    Supporting details

    2 participants
    L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75)
    Representative
    M. [R] (For: L'association départementale de réponse à l'urgence du département de Paris (ADRU 75))
    Paris Administrative Court

Matter record

Report a correction

ADRU 75 v MMA IARD (French Court of Cassation, pourvoi R 21-14.542) · Matter