Arbitral Digest

Matter

Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH v OÜ OMUL-FOT (FCC arbitration awards AA4542 and AA4543)

Applicable rules
FCC Arbitration and Appeal Rules
  1. 16 April 2019Arbitration

    16 April 2019Arbitration

    FCC arbitral award AA4542

    Federation of Cocoa Commerce

    Award no.
    AA4542
    Decision summary
    The FCC arbitral tribunal awarded Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH EUR 466,014.25 against OÜ OMUL-FOT, plus EUR 19,883.27 in interest at 6% per year from 3 August 2018 until the award date.

    Supporting details

    2 participants
    Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH
    OÜ OMUL-FOT
    Federation of Cocoa Commerce
  2. 16 April 2019Arbitration

    16 April 2019Arbitration

    FCC arbitral award AA4543

    Federation of Cocoa Commerce

    Award no.
    AA4543
    Decision summary
    The FCC arbitral tribunal awarded Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH EUR 133,172.20 against OÜ OMUL-FOT, plus EUR 5,482.26 in interest at 6% per year from 12 August 2018 until the award date.

    Supporting details

    2 participants
    Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH
    OÜ OMUL-FOT
    Federation of Cocoa Commerce

    3 years, 1 month and 15 days later · 1141 days

  3. 31 May 2022Estonia

    31 May 2022Estonia

    Harju County Court judgment dated 31 May 2022 in case 2-21-10111

    Harju County Court

    Case no.
    2-21-10111
    Decision summary
    The Harju County Court dismissed Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH's claim for recognition of its EUR 624,551.98 claim in OÜ OMUL-FOT's bankruptcy and ordered specified procedural costs; the Tallinn Court of Appeal later set this judgment aside.

    1 year and 5 months later · 518 days

  4. 31 October 2023Estonia

    31 October 2023Estonia

    Decision of the Tallinn Court of Appeal in case 2-21-10111/58 dated 31 October 2023

    Tallinn Court of Appeal

    Case no.
    2-21-10111
    Citation
    ECLI:EE:TLRK:2023:2.21.10111.23880
    Decision summary
    The Tallinn Court of Appeal allowed Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH's appeal, set aside the Harju County Court judgment, and recognized its EUR 624,551.98 claim in OÜ OMUL-FOT's bankruptcy as a second-ranking claim. The court ordered the bankruptcy trustee to bear the claimant's procedural costs and left the remaining procedural costs with the respective parties.

    Supporting details

    15 authorities · 14 participants
    Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH
    Representative
    Stig Hendrikson (For: Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH)
    AS Erst Finance
    Representative
    Olavi-Jüri Luik (For: AS Erst Finance · OÜ Realsten)
    OÜ Realsten
    Representative
    Olavi-Jüri Luik (For: AS Erst Finance · OÜ Realsten)
    OSAÜHING ALBERGRUPP TEENUSED
    Representative
    Eduard Neiman (For: OSAÜHING ALBERGRUPP TEENUSED)
    OÜ OMUL-FOT
    Representative
    Asko Pohla (For: OÜ OMUL-FOT)
    Representative
    Martin Männik (For: OÜ OMUL-FOT)
    Andrias Palmits
    Tallinn Court of Appeal

    Authorities cited

    15
    • Estonian Bankruptcy Act (PankrS)
      statute
    • Estonian Code of Civil Procedure (TsMS)
      statute
    • Estonian Law of Obligations Act (VÕS)
      statute
    • General Part of the Estonian Civil Code Act (TsÜS)
      statute
    • Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 on the law applicable to contractual obligations (Rome I Regulation) (Regulation (EC) No 593/2008)
      statute
    • Regulation (EU) 2015/848 on insolvency proceedings (recast) (Regulation (EU) 2015/848)
      statute
    • 1980 United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) (1980 United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods)
      statute
    • German Civil Code (BGB)
      statute
    • UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules, article 35(1)
      rules
    • Estonian Supreme Court Judgment dated 17 September 2001, No. 3-2-1-97-01 (3-2-1-97-01)
      case-law
    • Estonian Supreme Court Judgment dated 8 April 2015, No. 3-2-1-8-15 (3-2-1-8-15)
      case-law
    • Estonian Supreme Court Judgment dated 20 April 2016, No. 3-2-1-142-15 (3-2-1-142-15)
      case-law
    • Estonian Supreme Court Judgment No. 3-2-1-42-09 (3-2-1-42-09)
      case-law
    • Estonian Supreme Court Judgment No. 3-2-1-11-08 (3-2-1-11-08)
      case-law
    • MüKo, 9th edition (2021)
      academic
  5. Date not availableEstonia

    Date not availableEstonia

    Pärnu County Court decision in civil case 2-20-5797

    Pärnu County Court

    Case no.
    2-20-5797
    Decision summary
    The Pärnu County Court left Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH's applications to recognize the FCC arbitral awards without examination after OÜ OMUL-FOT became insolvent during the recognition proceedings.

Matter record

Report a correction

Albrecht & Dill Trading GmbH v OÜ OMUL-FOT (FCC arbitration awards AA4542 and AA4543) · Matter