Arbitral Digest

Matter

SAS Alloin Transports v Packard Bell BV et al. (Paris Court of Appeal 11/08983)

  1. 5 April 2011France

    5 April 2011France

    Judgment of the Créteil Commercial Court in case RG 2006F00657 dated 5 April 2011

    Créteil Commercial Court

    Case no.
    RG 2006F00657
    Decision summary
    The Créteil Commercial Court ordered Kuehne & Nagel to compensate Mitsui Sumitomo and Packard Bell BV for the stolen computer shipment, required Alloin Transports to guarantee Kuehne & Nagel, and made related awards of costs and procedural expenses.

    2 years, 6 months and 19 days later · 933 days

  2. 24 October 2013France

    24 October 2013France

    Decision of the Paris Court of Appeal, Pôle 5 - Chambre 5 in case 11/08983 dated 24 October 2013

    Paris Court of Appeal, Pôle 5 - Chambre 5

    Case no.
    11/08983
    Decision summary
    The Court of Appeal confirmed the Créteil Commercial Court's jurisdiction, reversed the appealed judgment on the claims, and declared Packard Bell BV, Packard Bell Iberia, Packard Bell Angers, Introduxi Comput Multimedia E Servicos, and Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Company (Europe) Limited inadmissible. It ordered those parties jointly to pay EUR 6,000 to Kuehne & Nagel, EUR 5,000 to Alloin Transports, and EUR 10,000 to the Pantoja parties and Groupama, together with the costs.

    Supporting details

    8 authorities · 20 participants
    SAS Alloin Transports
    Representative
    Alain Fisselier (For: SAS Alloin Transports · Generali France IARD SA · Zurich Insurance Ireland Limited)
    Packard Bell B.V.
    Representative
    Philippe Galland (For: Packard Bell B.V. · Packard Bell Angers SARL · Packard Bell Iberia SL · Introduxi Comput Multimedia e Servicos SA · Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Company (Europe) Limited)
    Packard Bell Angers SARL
    Representative
    Philippe Galland (For: Packard Bell B.V. · Packard Bell Angers SARL · Packard Bell Iberia SL · Introduxi Comput Multimedia e Servicos SA · Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Company (Europe) Limited)
    Packard Bell Iberia SL
    Representative
    Philippe Galland (For: Packard Bell B.V. · Packard Bell Angers SARL · Packard Bell Iberia SL · Introduxi Comput Multimedia e Servicos SA · Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Company (Europe) Limited)
    Introduxi Comput Multimedia e Servicos SA
    Representative
    Philippe Galland (For: Packard Bell B.V. · Packard Bell Angers SARL · Packard Bell Iberia SL · Introduxi Comput Multimedia e Servicos SA · Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Company (Europe) Limited)
    Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Company (Europe) Limited
    Representative
    Philippe Galland (For: Packard Bell B.V. · Packard Bell Angers SARL · Packard Bell Iberia SL · Introduxi Comput Multimedia e Servicos SA · Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Company (Europe) Limited)
    Kuehne + Nagel SAS
    Representative
    Luca De Maria (For: Kuehne + Nagel SAS)
    Transportes Juan Luis Pantoja e Hijos SL
    Representative
    Laurence Taze Bernard (For: Transportes Juan Luis Pantoja e Hijos SL · Division de Transportes JL Pantoja SLU · Groupama Seguros y Reaseguros SA)
    Division de Transportes JL Pantoja SLU
    Representative
    Laurence Taze Bernard (For: Transportes Juan Luis Pantoja e Hijos SL · Division de Transportes JL Pantoja SLU · Groupama Seguros y Reaseguros SA)
    Groupama Seguros y Reaseguros SA
    Representative
    Laurence Taze Bernard (For: Transportes Juan Luis Pantoja e Hijos SL · Division de Transportes JL Pantoja SLU · Groupama Seguros y Reaseguros SA)
    Generali France IARD SA
    Representative
    Alain Fisselier (For: SAS Alloin Transports · Generali France IARD SA · Zurich Insurance Ireland Limited)
    Zurich Insurance Ireland Limited
    Representative
    Alain Fisselier (For: SAS Alloin Transports · Generali France IARD SA · Zurich Insurance Ireland Limited)
    Paris Court of Appeal, Pôle 5 - Chambre 5
    Other
    Court Reporter
    Emmanuelle Damarey

    Authorities cited

    8
    • French Code of Civil Procedure
      statute
    • French Civil Code
      statute
    • French Insurance Code
      statute
    • French Commercial Code
      statute
    • Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR)
      statute
    • Marine Insurance Act 1906
      statute
    • Versailles Court of Appeal judgment of 19 June 2008
      case-law
    • Paris Court of Appeal judgment of 10 April 2013, Pôle 5 - Chambre 4
      case-law

Matter record

Report a correction

SAS Alloin Transports v Packard Bell BV et al. (Paris Court of Appeal 11/08983) · Matter