Matter
Aslan Shipping Corporation Monrovia v Supermarine (French Court of Cassation 79-16.063)
- 13 July 1979France
13 July 1979France
Judgment of the Rennes Court of Appeal dated 13 July 1979
Rennes Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The Rennes Court of Appeal held the shipowner liable to the cargo receivers after the captain refused to unload the vessel despite interim relief, liquidated the penalty for non-compliance, and awarded 5,000 French francs under article 700 of the French New Code of Civil Procedure to Central Soya International.
Supporting details
11 participantsSOCIETE ASLAN SHIPPING CORPORATION MONROVIA
SOCIETE SUPERMARINE
SUMA-TROP
SOCIETE CENTRAL SOYA INTERNATIONAL
Captain of X...
COMPTOIR COMMERCIAL ANDRE ET CIE
COMPAGNIE EUROPEENNE DE CEREALES
UNION NATIONALE DES COOPERATIVES AGRICOLES D'APPROVISIONNEMENT
GUYOMARC'H TALHOUET
SONASTOCK
AGENCE MARITIME CHARLES ALLAIRE
Rennes Court of Appeal
3 years, 9 months and 27 days later · 1397 days
- 10 May 1983France
10 May 1983France
Judgment of the French Court of Cassation, Commercial Chamber, in case 79-16.063 dated 10 May 1983
French Court of Cassation, Commercial Chamber
- Decision summary
- The Court of Cassation rejected the appeal against the Rennes Court of Appeal judgment of 13 July 1979. It upheld liquidation of the penalty for refusing to unload the vessel and the finding that the shipowner was delictually liable to the cargo receivers, and it upheld the award of 5,000 French francs under article 700 of the French New Code of Civil Procedure to Central Soya International.
Supporting details
2 authorities · 11 participantsSOCIETE ASLAN SHIPPING CORPORATION MONROVIA
Captain of X...
SOCIETE SUPERMARINE
SUMA-TROP
SOCIETE CENTRAL SOYA INTERNATIONAL
COMPTOIR COMMERCIAL ANDRE ET CIE
COMPAGNIE EUROPEENNE DE CEREALES
UNION NATIONALE DES COOPERATIVES AGRICOLES D'APPROVISIONNEMENT
GUYOMARC'H TALHOUET
SONASTOCK
AGENCE MARITIME CHARLES ALLAIRE
French Court of Cassation, Commercial Chamber
- Date not availableFrance
Date not availableFrance
Interim Relief Order Requiring X... to Be Unloaded Subject to a Penalty
- Decision summary
- An interim-relief order required the vessel X... to be unloaded under a penalty. The order became irrevocable, but the captain continued to refuse unloading.
- Date not availableFrance
Date not availableFrance
Second Interim Relief Order Authorizing the Deposit of the Goods
- Decision summary
- A second interim-relief order authorized consignment of the cargo after the captain, acting as the shipowner's representative, relied on article 18 of the charterparty and article 3 of the Decree of 31 December 1966.