Matter
B. KG v R. S. (Supreme Court of Poland I CSK 464/16)
- 14 December 2006Arbitration
14 December 2006Arbitration
Ad hoc arbitral award of 14 December 2006
- Decision summary
- The ad hoc arbitral tribunal ordered B. KG to pay R. S. EUR 105,563.83, with interest and arbitration costs, for remuneration for November and December 2004 and the 2004 annual bonus. The award was later set aside in part by the Regional Court in W.
Supporting details
5 participants1 year, 2 months and 21 days later · 448 days
- 6 March 2008Poland
6 March 2008Poland
Judgment of the Regional Court in W. dated 6 March 2008
Regional Court in W., Poland
- Decision summary
- The Regional Court in W. set aside the 14 December 2006 ad hoc arbitral award in the part ordering payment to R. S. because B. KG was not effectively notified of the arbitration and was deprived of the opportunity to defend its rights.
Supporting details
2 participantsB. KG
R. S.
Regional Court in W., Poland
4 years, 8 months and 15 days later · 1721 days
- 21 November 2012Arbitration
21 November 2012Arbitration
Ad hoc arbitral award of 21 November 2012
- Decision summary
- After the tribunal was reconstituted and the arbitration proceeded with B. KG's participation, the tribunal ordered B. KG to pay R. S. EUR 104,963.83 with statutory interest as the principal claim and PLN 23,500 as reimbursement of proceedings costs. The award was set aside in the challenged scope by the Regional Court in W. and the Court of Appeal later dismissed the setting-aside application.
Supporting details
5 participants2 years and 21 days later · 751 days
- 12 December 2014Poland
12 December 2014Poland
Judgment of the Regional Court in W. dated 12 December 2014
Regional Court in W., Poland
- Decision summary
- The Regional Court in W. set aside the 21 November 2012 ad hoc arbitral award in the challenged scope, holding that the tribunal's three-member composition did not comply with the applicable appointment arrangement and that the award conflicted with fundamental principles of the Polish legal order.
Supporting details
2 participantsB. KG
R. S.
Regional Court in W., Poland
1 year and 4 days later · 369 days
- 16 December 2015Poland
16 December 2015Poland
Judgment of the Court of Appeal in (…) dated 16 December 2015
Court of Appeal in (…), Poland
- Decision summary
- The Court of Appeal amended the Regional Court's judgment and dismissed B. KG's application to set aside the 21 November 2012 ad hoc arbitral award.
Supporting details
2 participantsB. KG
R. S.
Court of Appeal in (…), Poland
1 year, 5 months and 10 days later · 527 days
- 26 May 2017Poland
26 May 2017Poland
Judgment of the Supreme Court of Poland in case I CSK 464/16 dated 26 May 2017
Supreme Court of Poland
- Citation
- I CSK 464/16
- Decision summary
- The Supreme Court dismissed B. KG's cassation appeal against the Court of Appeal judgment concerning the setting aside of the 21 November 2012 ad hoc arbitral award and ordered B. KG to pay R. S. PLN 1,800 in cassation-proceeding costs. It held that the Court of Appeal correctly rejected the challenges concerning tribunal composition, the binding effect of the 2008 judgment, and limitation of the underlying claim.
Supporting details
27 authorities · 6 participantsB. KG
R. S.
Supreme Court of Poland
- Judge
- Marta Romańska
- Judge
- Józef Frąckowiak
- Judge
- Paweł Grzegorczyk
Other
- Court Reporter
- Ewa Krentzel