Arbitral Digest

Matter

S.A.R.L. BLOW PACK v WINDMOLLER & HOLSCHER KG (Paris Court of Appeal 11/18244)

Applicable rules
ICC Rules of Arbitration
  1. 25 May 2009Arbitration

    2 years, 3 months and 20 days later · 842 days

  2. 14 September 2011Arbitration

    14 September 2011Arbitration

    Final Arbitral Award issued in Paris on 14 September 2011

    International Chamber of Commerce

    Decision summary
    The tribunal declared WINDMOLLER's counterclaims concerning the VAREX machine admissible and ordered BLOW PACK to pay compensation for termination-related damage, storage, and unjustified calls on guarantees, with interest. For the FILMEX machine, it ordered BLOW PACK to pay the final price instalment and guarantee-related costs, ordered WINDMOLLER to pay BLOW PACK €31,050 for lost profit, allocated arbitration and defence costs between the parties, charged BLOW PACK with the expert costs, and rejected the remaining claims.

    Supporting details

    5 participants
    S.A.R.L. BLOW PACK
    WINDMOLLER & HOLSCHER KG
    International Chamber of Commerce
    Arbitrator
    M. [R] [I]
    Arbitrator
    MM. [J] [H]
    Arbitrator
    T. W. [K]

    1 year, 6 months and 19 days later · 566 days

  3. 2 April 2013France

    2 April 2013France

    Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal in case 11/18244 dated 2 April 2013

    Paris Court of Appeal, Pôle 1 - Chamber 1

    Case no.
    11/18244
    Decision summary
    The Paris Court of Appeal rejected BLOW PACK's request to stay the annulment proceedings, partially annulled the 14 September 2011 arbitral award insofar as it concerned the FILMEX machine because the tribunal had breached the principle of adversarial proceedings by relying on partially translated evidence, and rejected the remaining claims. It ordered WINDMOLLER & HOLSCHER KG to pay the costs and €30,000 under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.

    Supporting details

    2 authorities · 12 participants
    S.A.R.L. BLOW PACK
    Representative
    SELARL PELLERIN - DE MARIA - GUERRE (For: S.A.R.L. BLOW PACK)
    Representative
    Luca DE MARIA (For: S.A.R.L. BLOW PACK)
    Representative
    Valence BORGIA (For: S.A.R.L. BLOW PACK)
    WINDMOLLER & HOLSCHER KG
    Representative
    Pascale FLAURAUD (For: WINDMOLLER & HOLSCHER KG)
    Representative
    Elisabeth HOFFMANN (For: WINDMOLLER & HOLSCHER KG)
    Representative
    Sabine PERQUY FORKE (For: WINDMOLLER & HOLSCHER KG)
    Paris Court of Appeal, Pôle 1 - Chamber 1
    Judge
    DALLERY
    Other
    Court Reporter
    PATE

    Authorities cited

    2
    • French Code of Civil Procedure
      statute
    • French Code of Criminal Procedure
      statute

Matter record

Report a correction

S.A.R.L. BLOW PACK v WINDMOLLER & HOLSCHER KG (Paris Court of Appeal 11/18244) · Matter