Matter
Chelleri and Others v. Croatia (ECtHR applications nos. 49358/22, 49562/22 and 54489/22)
- 7 January 2021Croatia
7 January 2021Croatia
Pazin Municipal Court judgment concerning Rene Chelleri dated 7 January 2021
Pazin Municipal Court
- Decision summary
- The court found Rene Chelleri guilty of fifteen minor offences under the Croatian State Border Surveillance Act.
Supporting details
1 participantRene Chelleri
Pazin Municipal Court
4 months and 19 days later · 139 days
- 26 May 2021Croatia
26 May 2021Croatia
High Minor Offences Court judgment concerning Rene Chelleri dated 26 May 2021
High Minor Offences Court of the Republic of Croatia
- Decision summary
- The court dismissed Rene Chelleri’s appeal and upheld his convictions for the minor offences.
Supporting details
1 participantRene Chelleri
High Minor Offences Court of the Republic of Croatia
5 months and 24 days later · 177 days
- 19 November 2021Croatia
19 November 2021Croatia
Pazin Municipal Court judgment concerning Robert Radolovič dated 19 November 2021
Pazin Municipal Court
- Decision summary
- The court found Robert Radolovič guilty of ten minor offences under the Croatian Marine Fisheries Act and related European Union provisions.
Supporting details
1 participantRobert Radolovič
Pazin Municipal Court
18 days later · 18 days
- 7 December 2021Croatia
7 December 2021Croatia
Pazin Municipal Court judgment concerning Jan Virant dated 7 December 2021
Pazin Municipal Court
- Decision summary
- The court found Jan Virant guilty of six minor offences under the Croatian Marine Fisheries Act and related European Union provisions.
Supporting details
1 participantJan Virant
Pazin Municipal Court
20 days later · 20 days
- 27 December 2021Croatia
27 December 2021Croatia
High Minor Offences Court judgment concerning Robert Radolovič dated 27 December 2021
High Minor Offences Court of the Republic of Croatia
- Decision summary
- The court dismissed Robert Radolovič’s appeal and upheld his convictions for the minor offences.
Supporting details
1 participantRobert Radolovič
High Minor Offences Court of the Republic of Croatia
16 days later · 16 days
- 12 January 2022Croatia
12 January 2022Croatia
High Minor Offences Court judgment concerning Jan Virant dated 12 January 2022
High Minor Offences Court of the Republic of Croatia
- Decision summary
- The court dismissed Jan Virant’s appeal and upheld his convictions for the minor offences.
Supporting details
1 participantJan Virant
High Minor Offences Court of the Republic of Croatia
4 months and 21 days later · 141 days
- 2 June 2022Croatia
2 June 2022Croatia
Croatian Constitutional Court decision concerning the applicants dated 2 June 2022
Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia
- Decision summary
- The Constitutional Court dismissed the applicants’ constitutional complaint as unfounded, holding that the domestic decisions complied with relevant law and that the minor offences were clearly defined and foreseeable.
Supporting details
3 participantsRene Chelleri
Robert Radolovič
Jan Virant
Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia
27 days later · 27 days
- 29 June 2022Croatia
29 June 2022Croatia
Croatian Constitutional Court decision concerning the applicants dated 29 June 2022
Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia
- Decision summary
- The Constitutional Court dismissed the applicants’ constitutional complaint as unfounded, referring to its findings that the domestic decisions complied with relevant law and that the minor offences were clearly defined and foreseeable.
Supporting details
3 participantsRene Chelleri
Robert Radolovič
Jan Virant
Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia
1 year, 10 months and 17 days later · 687 days
- 16 May 2024International
16 May 2024International
Decision of the European Court of Human Rights (Second Section) in the case Chelleri and Others v. Croatia, applications nos. 49358/22, 49562/22 and 54489/22, dated 16 May 2024
European Court of Human Rights (Second Section)
- Citation
- Applications nos. 49358/22, 49562/22 and 54489/22
- Decision summary
- The Court joined the three applications and declared them inadmissible as manifestly ill-founded under Articles 35 §§ 3(a) and 4 of the Convention. It held that the applicants could reasonably foresee that their conduct in the disputed maritime waters would constitute minor offences under Croatian law, and that it was not for the Court to rule on the validity or legal effects of the Croatia–Slovenia Arbitration Agreement or Arbitration Award.
Supporting details
37 authorities · 16 participantsRene Chelleri
Robert Radolovič
Jan Virant
- Representative
- M. Menard (For: Rene Chelleri · Robert Radolovič · Jan Virant)
Croatia
- Representative
- Š. Stažnik (For: Croatia)
Slovenia
European Court of Human Rights (Second Section)
- Judge
- Arnfinn Bårdsen
- Judge
- Pauliine Koskelo
- Judge
- Frédéric Krenc
- Judge
- Diana Sârcu
- Judge
- Saadet Yüksel
Other
- Institutional administrator
- Hasan Bakırcı