Matter
Cabinet de maîtrise d'oeuvre CMO and Monsieur [O] [I] v SNC Lavalin International and SNC Lavalin (Paris Court of Appeal 15/02650)
- 19 January 2015France
19 January 2015France
Judgment of the Paris Commercial Court dated 19 January 2015
Paris Commercial Court
- Decision summary
- The Paris Commercial Court declared itself competent to hear CMO and Monsieur [O] [I]'s claims, stayed proceedings on SNC Lavalin Europe's request to be removed from the case, and adjourned the matter for submissions on the merits; the Paris Court of Appeal later displaced that jurisdiction ruling.
Supporting details
5 participantsSNC Lavalin International
SNC Lavalin
SNC Lavalin Europe
Cabinet de maîtrise d'oeuvre CMO
Monsieur [O] [I]
Paris Commercial Court
4 months and 30 days later · 150 days
- 18 June 2015France
18 June 2015France
Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal, Division 1 - Chamber 2 in the case 15/02650 dated 18 June 2015
Paris Court of Appeal, Division 1 - Chamber 2
- Decision summary
- The Paris Court of Appeal upheld the appeal on jurisdiction, declared the Paris Commercial Court incompetent to hear CMO and Monsieur [O] [I]'s claims against SNC Lavalin International because the five Moroccan project contracts contained ICC arbitration clauses, and declared the Paris Commercial Court incompetent in favour of the Commercial Court of Créteil for the claims against SNC Lavalin. It referred CMO and Monsieur [O] [I] to seek relief elsewhere as against SNC Lavalin International and awarded costs and Article 700 sums.
Supporting details
2 authorities · 13 participantsSASU SNC-LAVALIN INTERNATIONAL
- Representative
- Me Pierre LEVEQUE (For: SASU SNC-LAVALIN INTERNATIONAL · SASU SNC LAVALIN · SASU SNC LAVALIN EUROPE)
- Representative
- AARPI DENTONS EUROPE (For: SASU SNC-LAVALIN INTERNATIONAL · SASU SNC LAVALIN · SASU SNC LAVALIN EUROPE)
SASU SNC LAVALIN
- Representative
- Me Pierre LEVEQUE (For: SASU SNC-LAVALIN INTERNATIONAL · SASU SNC LAVALIN · SASU SNC LAVALIN EUROPE)
- Representative
- AARPI DENTONS EUROPE (For: SASU SNC-LAVALIN INTERNATIONAL · SASU SNC LAVALIN · SASU SNC LAVALIN EUROPE)
SASU SNC LAVALIN EUROPE
- Representative
- Me Pierre LEVEQUE (For: SASU SNC-LAVALIN INTERNATIONAL · SASU SNC LAVALIN · SASU SNC LAVALIN EUROPE)
- Representative
- AARPI DENTONS EUROPE (For: SASU SNC-LAVALIN INTERNATIONAL · SASU SNC LAVALIN · SASU SNC LAVALIN EUROPE)
SARL CABINET MAITRISE D'OEUVRE C.M.O
- Representative
- Me Jean-david COHEN (For: SARL CABINET MAITRISE D'OEUVRE C.M.O · Monsieur [O] [I])
- Representative
- AARPI JAD & ASSOCIES (For: SARL CABINET MAITRISE D'OEUVRE C.M.O · Monsieur [O] [I])
Monsieur [O] [I]
- Representative
- Me Jean-david COHEN (For: SARL CABINET MAITRISE D'OEUVRE C.M.O · Monsieur [O] [I])
- Representative
- AARPI JAD & ASSOCIES (For: SARL CABINET MAITRISE D'OEUVRE C.M.O · Monsieur [O] [I])
Paris Court of Appeal, Division 1 - Chamber 2
- Judge
- Madame Evelyne LOUYS
Other
- Court Reporter
- Mme Sonia DAIRAIN