Arbitral Digest

Matter

CSM Bessac, GBH and CASH v SDV Logistique Internationale, Generali IARD and others (Paris Court of Appeal 12/22419)

  1. 25 October 2012France

    25 October 2012France

    Judgment of the Paris Commercial Court in case RG 2007070728 dated 25 October 2012

    Paris Commercial Court

    Case no.
    RG 2007070728
    Decision summary
    The court joined the proceedings under RG numbers 2007070728, 2007072568 and 2010073681; rejected or dismissed claims against SDV Logistique Internationale; held Transports et Locations Courcelle liable for 50% of the tunnelier loss; fixed CASH's recovery at €30,000 for material damage and €31,000 for other damage; and ordered Groupama Transport to indemnify Courcelle for those sums.

    1 year, 1 month and 10 days later · 406 days

  2. 5 December 2013France

    5 December 2013France

    Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal in case 12/22419 dated 5 December 2013

    Paris Court of Appeal, Pôle 5 - Chambre 5

    Case no.
    12/22419
    Decision summary
    The court declared CSM Bessac's claim admissible, held that SDV Logistique Internationale acted as a transport broker, and held SDV and Generali IARD jointly liable to pay CASH €122,000 with statutory interest and capitalization. It held Courcelle and Groupama Transport liable to indemnify SDV and Generali for those awards, rejected the remaining claims, and awarded CASH €10,000 in procedural costs against SDV, Generali, Courcelle and Helvetia, jointly and severally.

    Supporting details

    3 authorities · 24 participants
    Compagnie d'Assurance des Hydrocarbures CASH SPA
    Representative
    Anne Grappotte-Benetreau (For: Compagnie d'Assurance des Hydrocarbures CASH SPA · GBH Groupement CSM Bessac/Hydro Technique · CSM Bessac)
    Representative
    Pierre Yves Guerin (For: Compagnie d'Assurance des Hydrocarbures CASH SPA · GBH Groupement CSM Bessac/Hydro Technique · CSM Bessac)
    GBH Groupement CSM Bessac/Hydro Technique
    Representative
    Anne Grappotte-Benetreau (For: Compagnie d'Assurance des Hydrocarbures CASH SPA · GBH Groupement CSM Bessac/Hydro Technique · CSM Bessac)
    Representative
    Pierre Yves Guerin (For: Compagnie d'Assurance des Hydrocarbures CASH SPA · GBH Groupement CSM Bessac/Hydro Technique · CSM Bessac)
    CSM Bessac
    Representative
    Anne Grappotte-Benetreau (For: Compagnie d'Assurance des Hydrocarbures CASH SPA · GBH Groupement CSM Bessac/Hydro Technique · CSM Bessac)
    Representative
    Pierre Yves Guerin (For: Compagnie d'Assurance des Hydrocarbures CASH SPA · GBH Groupement CSM Bessac/Hydro Technique · CSM Bessac)
    Generali IARD
    Representative
    Nadia Bouzidi-Fabre (For: Generali IARD · SDV Logistique Internationale)
    SDV Logistique Internationale
    Representative
    Nadia Bouzidi-Fabre (For: Generali IARD · SDV Logistique Internationale)
    Representative
    Sylvie Neige (For: SDV Logistique Internationale)
    Transports et Locations Courcelle
    Representative
    Laurence Taze Bernard (For: Transports et Locations Courcelle)
    Representative
    Cecile Chapeau (For: Transports et Locations Courcelle)
    GAN Eurocourtage
    Representative
    Edmond Fromantin (For: GAN Eurocourtage · Helvetia Assurances)
    Representative
    Jerome de Sentenac (For: GAN Eurocourtage · Helvetia Assurances)
    Helvetia Assurances
    Representative
    Edmond Fromantin (For: GAN Eurocourtage · Helvetia Assurances)
    Representative
    Jerome de Sentenac (For: GAN Eurocourtage · Helvetia Assurances)
    Cabinet Levesque
    Representative
    Luc Couturier (For: Cabinet Levesque)
    Representative
    Pascal Huchet (For: Cabinet Levesque)
    Paris Court of Appeal, Pôle 5 - Chambre 5
    Other
    Court Reporter
    Emmanuelle Damarey
    Expert
    M. [E]

    Authorities cited

    3
    • French Code of Civil Procedure
      statute
    • French Civil Code
      statute
    • French Commercial Code
      statute

Matter record

Report a correction

CSM Bessac, GBH and CASH v SDV Logistique Internationale, Generali IARD and others (Paris Court of Appeal 12/22419) · Matter