Arbitral Digest

Matter

E. Joint-Stock Company in C. v S. Limited in N. and S. in N. (Supreme Court of Poland V CSKP 64/21)

Seat
Cyprus
  1. 10 March 2021Poland

    10 March 2021Poland

    Decision of the Supreme Court of Poland in the case V CSKP 64/21 dated 10 March 2021

    Supreme Court of Poland

    Case no.
    V CSKP 64/21
    Citation
    V CSKP 64/21
    Decision summary
    The Supreme Court quashed the appellate orders in their entirety and remanded the matter for reconsideration. It held that the share-sale agreements and their arbitration clauses were invalid because N. J. had never been a member of the claimant company’s management board, the agreements were not confirmed by that company, and the circumstances undermined the defendants’ good faith; the arbitration clauses therefore could not support dismissal of the claims for delivery.

    Supporting details

    27 authorities · 9 participants
    E. Joint-Stock Company in C.
    Representative
    N. J. (For: E. Joint-Stock Company in C.)
    S. Limited in N.
    Representative
    M. K. (For: S. Limited in N.)
    S. in N.
    Supreme Court of Poland
    Other
    Witness
    C. C.

    Authorities cited

    27
    • Polish Civil Code
      statute
    • Polish Code of Civil Procedure
      statute
    • Polish National Court Register Act
      statute
    • Polish Penal Code
      statute
    • Polish Commercial Companies Code
      statute
    • Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards
      treaty
    • III CZP 124/08, OSNC 2009, no. 11, item 146 (III CZP 124/08)
      case-law
    • V CSK 44/11
      case-law
    • II CK 341/10
      case-law
    • I CKN 1133/98
      case-law
    • II CK 413/04
      case-law
    • II CSK 180/09
      case-law
    • V CKN 437/00
      case-law
    • II CSK 626/09
      case-law
    • V CSK 284/13
      case-law
    • IV CKN 216/00
      case-law
    • IV CKN 1862/00
      case-law
    • III CSK 149/05
      case-law
    • II PK 64/12
      case-law
    • V CK 839/04
      case-law
    • II PZ 15/16
      case-law
    • III CKN 682/98
      case-law
    • II CKN 1415/00
      case-law
    • I CK 54/03
      case-law
    • III CZP 31/07, OSNC 2008, no. 2, item 14 (III CZP 31/07)
      case-law
    • II CSK 482/12
      case-law
    • II CSK 744/11
      case-law

Matter record

Report a correction

E. Joint-Stock Company in C. v S. Limited in N. and S. in N. (Supreme Court of Poland V CSKP 64/21) · Matter