Arbitral Digest

Matter

GIE Transmanche Construction v Co-insurers

  1. 2 June 2002France

    2 June 2002France

    Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal dated 2 June 2002

    Paris Court of Appeal

    Decision summary
    The Paris Court of Appeal held that AXA Corporate and Commercial Union Assurance Company owed coverage for the costs of replacing the entire Wet Systems network and remitted the parties to determine the indemnity.

    Supporting details

    3 participants
    GIE Transmanche Construction
    AXA Corporate
    Commercial Union Assurance Company
    Paris Court of Appeal

    4 months later · 122 days

  2. 2 October 2002France

    2 October 2002France

    Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal dated 2 October 2002

    Paris Court of Appeal

    Decision summary
    The Paris Court of Appeal held that AXA Corporate and Commercial Union Assurance Company owed coverage for the costs of replacing the entire Wet Systems network.

    Supporting details

    3 participants
    GIE Transmanche Construction
    AXA Corporate
    Commercial Union Assurance Company
    Paris Court of Appeal

    2 years, 2 months and 20 days later · 812 days

  3. 22 December 2004Arbitration

    22 December 2004Arbitration

    Arbitral Award dated 22 December 2004

    Supporting details

    3 participants
    GIE Transmanche Construction
    AXA Corporate
    Commercial Union Assurance Company

    3 years, 8 months and 25 days later · 1364 days

  4. 16 September 2008France

    16 September 2008France

    Judgment of the Paris Regional Court in the case RG 06/04771 dated 16 September 2008

    Paris Regional Court

    Case no.
    RG 06/04771
    Decision summary
    The Paris Regional Court held that GIE Transmanche Construction had standing and that its claims were admissible, declared its insurance-payment action time-barred, dismissed its claims against ACRE as inadmissible, and ordered the GIE to pay ACRE EUR 5,000 under Article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.

    Supporting details

    2 participants
    GIE Transmanche Construction
    ACRE
    Paris Regional Court

    2 years, 11 months and 28 days later · 1092 days

  5. 13 September 2011France

    13 September 2011France

    Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal in the case 08/19325 dated 13 September 2011

    Paris Court of Appeal, Division 2 - Chamber 5

    Case no.
    08/19325
    Decision summary
    The Paris Court of Appeal rejected the 22 December 2004 arbitral award from the evidence, reversed the first-instance decision except as to ACRE, dismissed GIE Transmanche Construction's claims against the co-insurers, and ordered the GIE to pay costs and the specified Article 700 awards.

    Supporting details

    6 authorities · 31 participants
    GIE Transmanche Construction
    Representative
    M. [M] [H] (For: GIE Transmanche Construction)
    Representative
    Me Teytaud (For: GIE Transmanche Construction)
    Representative
    Me Emmanuelle Payrau-Sorba (For: GIE Transmanche Construction)
    Representative
    DLA Piper (For: GIE Transmanche Construction)
    Aviva
    Representative
    SCP Roblin-Chaix-de Lavarene-Roblin (For: Aviva)
    Representative
    Me Eric Le Fevre (For: Aviva)
    ACRE
    Representative
    Me Huyghe (For: ACRE)
    Representative
    Me Nathalie Finkelstein (For: ACRE)
    Generali
    Representative
    SCP Fanet-Serra (For: Generali)
    Representative
    Me Carine Detre (For: Generali)
    Representative
    Association Beldev (For: Generali)
    GAN Eurocourtage IA
    Representative
    SCP Grappotte-Benetreau et Petit-Jumel (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    Me Catherine Boyvineau (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    SCP Naba & Associés (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Allianz IARD
    Representative
    SCP Grappotte-Benetreau et Petit-Jumel (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    Me Catherine Boyvineau (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    SCP Naba & Associés (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    SMABTP
    Representative
    SCP Grappotte-Benetreau et Petit-Jumel (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    Me Catherine Boyvineau (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    SCP Naba & Associés (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Gerling Konzern
    Representative
    SCP Grappotte-Benetreau et Petit-Jumel (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    Me Catherine Boyvineau (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    SCP Naba & Associés (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Albingia
    Representative
    SCP Grappotte-Benetreau et Petit-Jumel (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    Me Catherine Boyvineau (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    SCP Naba & Associés (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    MMA IARD
    Representative
    SCP Grappotte-Benetreau et Petit-Jumel (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    Me Catherine Boyvineau (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    SCP Naba & Associés (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Swiss Life
    Representative
    SCP Grappotte-Benetreau et Petit-Jumel (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    Me Catherine Boyvineau (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Representative
    SCP Naba & Associés (For: GAN Eurocourtage IA · Allianz IARD · SMABTP · Gerling Konzern · Albingia · MMA IARD · Swiss Life)
    Paris Court of Appeal, Division 2 - Chamber 5
    Other
    Institutional administrator
    Dominique Bonhomme-Auclere
    Institutional administrator
    Fatia Henni
    Expert
    [L]

    Authorities cited

    6
    • French Insurance Code
      statute
    • French Commercial Code
      statute
    • French Code of Civil Procedure
      statute
    • Judgment dated 21 November 2000 (French Court of Cassation judgment of 21 November 2000)
      case-law
    • Judgment of 2 June 2002 (Paris Court of Appeal judgment of 2 June 2002)
      case-law
    • Judgment dated 2 October 2002 (Paris Court of Appeal judgment of 2 October 2002)
      case-law

Matter record

Report a correction

GIE Transmanche Construction v Co-insurers · Matter