Matter
Gorthy Anil Kumar v PAG Holdings Limited (Hong Kong High Court HCA 3040/2016 and HCMP 282/2017)
- 15 May 2017Hong Kong
15 May 2017Hong Kong
Partial Award on Joinder and Jurisdiction dated 15 May 2017
International Chamber of Commerce International Court of Arbitration
- Decision summary
- The tribunal found the request to join Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited inadmissible, held that it had no jurisdiction over the disputes between that company and Gorthy Anil Kumar, dismissed the company from the arbitration, dismissed the other relief sought in connection with joinder, and reserved the remaining claims for a future award.
Supporting details
3 participantsGorthy Anil Kumar
PAG Holdings Limited
Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited
International Chamber of Commerce International Court of Arbitration
1 month and 3 days later · 34 days
- 18 June 2017Hong Kong
18 June 2017Hong Kong
Supplementary Award dated 18 June 2017
International Chamber of Commerce International Court of Arbitration
- Decision summary
- The tribunal declined the respondent's invitation to terminate the arbitration, directed that PAG Holdings Limited's claims and Gorthy Anil Kumar's counterclaims would be adjudicated, and gave further procedural directions. Reasons were issued on 30 June 2017.
Supporting details
1 authority · 2 participantsGorthy Anil Kumar
PAG Holdings Limited
International Chamber of Commerce International Court of Arbitration
1 month and 3 days later · 33 days
- 21 July 2017Hong Kong
21 July 2017Hong Kong
Decision of the High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, Court of First Instance in the cases HCA 3040/2016 and HCMP 282/2017 dated 21 July 2017
High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, Court of First Instance
- Decision summary
- The court declined to stay HCA 3040/2016 in favour of the ICC arbitration and declined to grant an anti-suit injunction in HCMP 282/2017. It ordered Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited and PAG Consulting Limited to pay Gorthy Anil Kumar's costs of the stay summons, and PAG Holdings Limited to pay his costs of the originating summons, with a certificate for counsel in both cases.
Supporting details
12 authorities · 11 participants- Application
- Stay application in HCA 3040/2016 — Declined
- Application
- Anti-suit injunction application in HCMP 282/2017 — Declined
Gorthy Anil Kumar
- Representative
- Jin Pao (For: Gorthy Anil Kumar)
- Representative
- Sarah Tong (For: Gorthy Anil Kumar)
- Representative
- Reed Smith Richards Butler (For: Gorthy Anil Kumar)
Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited
- Representative
- Jose-Antonio Maurellet (For: Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited · PAG Consulting Limited · PAG Holdings Limited)
- Representative
- Tom Ng (For: Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited · PAG Consulting Limited · PAG Holdings Limited)
- Representative
- Simmons & Simmons (For: Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited · PAG Consulting Limited · PAG Holdings Limited)
PAG Consulting Limited
- Representative
- Jose-Antonio Maurellet (For: Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited · PAG Consulting Limited · PAG Holdings Limited)
- Representative
- Tom Ng (For: Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited · PAG Consulting Limited · PAG Holdings Limited)
- Representative
- Simmons & Simmons (For: Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited · PAG Consulting Limited · PAG Holdings Limited)
PAG Holdings Limited
- Representative
- Jose-Antonio Maurellet (For: Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited · PAG Consulting Limited · PAG Holdings Limited)
- Representative
- Tom Ng (For: Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited · PAG Consulting Limited · PAG Holdings Limited)
- Representative
- Simmons & Simmons (For: Pacific Alliance Investment Management (HK) Limited · PAG Consulting Limited · PAG Holdings Limited)
High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, Court of First Instance
- Judge
- John Saunders