Matter
IBS Soft Solutions Group v Zao Rousskaya Lizingovaya Kompanya (French Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, no. N 15-14.768)
- 30 August 2011Russian Federation
30 August 2011Russian Federation
Judgment of the Moscow Commercial Court dated 30 August 2011
Moscow Commercial Court
- Decision summary
- The Moscow Commercial Court ordered IBS Soft Solutions Group to pay Mosmart EUR 300,000 in principal, EUR 6,997.57 in accrued interest, and 83,361.09 Russian roubles in court costs under the 29 April 2008 loan.
Supporting details
1 authority · 2 participantsMosmart
IBS Soft Solutions Group
Moscow Commercial Court
1 month and 10 days later · 41 days
- 10 October 2011Russian Federation
10 October 2011Russian Federation
Enforceable title issued by the Moscow Commercial Court on 10 October 2011
Moscow Commercial Court
- Decision summary
- The Moscow Commercial Court issued an enforceable title to Mosmart after the 30 August 2011 judgment became final when no appeal was filed by 30 September 2011.
Supporting details
2 participantsMosmart
IBS Soft Solutions Group
Moscow Commercial Court
11 months and 11 days later · 347 days
- 21 September 2012Russian Federation
21 September 2012Russian Federation
Order of the Moscow Commercial Court dated 21 September 2012
Moscow Commercial Court
- Decision summary
- The Moscow Commercial Court ordered the substitution of Zao Rousskaya Lizingovaya Kompanya for Promkommertz in the rights arising from Mosmart's judgment against IBS Soft Solutions Group.
Supporting details
4 participantsZao Rousskaya Lizingovaya Kompanya
IBS Soft Solutions Group
Mosmart
Promkommertz
Moscow Commercial Court
2 years, 3 months and 25 days later · 846 days
- 15 January 2015France
15 January 2015France
Judgment of the Douai Court of Appeal, Chamber 8, Section 3 dated 15 January 2015
Douai Court of Appeal, Chamber 8, Section 3
- Decision summary
- The Douai Court of Appeal granted exequatur in France to the Moscow Commercial Court judgment against IBS Soft Solutions Group in favour of Zao Rousskaya Lizingovaya Kompanya.
Supporting details
2 participantsIBS Soft Solutions Group
Zao Rousskaya Lizingovaya Kompanya
Douai Court of Appeal, Chamber 8, Section 3
2 years, 2 months and 7 days later · 797 days
- 22 March 2017France
22 March 2017France
Judgment of the French Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, no. 15-14.768 dated 22 March 2017
French Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber
- Citation
- Arrêt n° 386 F-D
- Decision summary
- The Court of Cassation dismissed IBS Soft Solutions Group's appeal and upheld the exequatur in France of the Moscow Commercial Court judgment ordering IBS to pay sums owed under a loan. It held that service, the opportunity to defend, notification, and the substitution of Zao Rousskaya Lizingovaya Kompanya for Mosmart were sufficient for compliance with international procedural public policy, and ordered IBS to pay costs and EUR 3,000 under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.
Supporting details
3 authorities · 9 participantsIBS Soft Solutions Group
- Representative
- SCP Le Bret-Desaché (For: IBS Soft Solutions Group)
Zao Rousskaya Lizingovaya Kompanya
- Representative
- SCP Lyon-Caen et Thiriez (For: Zao Rousskaya Lizingovaya Kompanya)
French Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber
- Judge
- Batut
- Judge
- Acquaviva
- Judge
- Matet
- Advocate General
- Ingall-Montagnier
Other
- Institutional administrator
- Pecquenard