Matter
Renee Rose Levy de Levi and Gremcitel S.A. v. Republic of Peru (ICSID Case No. ARB/11/17)
ICSID arbitration concerning Renee Rose Levy de Levi and Gremcitel’s claims against Peru and the tribunal’s jurisdictional decision.
Procedural record
- 9 January 2015Arbitration
9 January 2015Arbitration
Award dated 9 January 2015
International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes
- Decision summary
- The Tribunal unanimously decided that it was precluded from exercising jurisdiction over the dispute. It ordered the Claimants to reimburse the Respondent the amounts deposited with ICSID for the costs of the arbitration, to pay USD 1,571,858.72 to the Respondent as a contribution to legal fees and other expenses, and dismissed all other requests for relief.
Participants
Renee Rose Levy
- Representative
- Carlos Paitan Contreras (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Representative
- Christian Carbajal Valenzuela (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Representative
- Jose Salcedo Machado (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Representative
- Danny Quiroga Anticona (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Representative
- Fernando Olivares Placido (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Representative
- Isy Ralph Levy Calvo (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Expert
- John Ferro (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Representative
- Estudio Paitan & Abogados (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Expert
- Claudette Joseph (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Expert
- Ian Sandy (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Expert
- Cristobal Aljovin (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Expert
- Richard Martin (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Expert
- Martin D'Azevedo (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Expert
- Richard Marchitelli (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Expert
- Jose Rivas (For: Renee Rose Levy)
- Expert
- David Benick (For: Renee Rose Levy)
Gremcitel S.A.
Republic of Peru
- Representative
- Carlos Valderrama Bernal (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Stanimir Alexandrov (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Jennifer Haworth McCandless (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Marinn Carlson (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Juan Pazos (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Jorge Masson (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Ricardo Puccio (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Francisco Navarro Grau (For: Republic of Peru)
- Expert
- Sheila Harris (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Sidley Austin LLP (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Estudio Navarro, Ferrero & Pazos (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Andrew Blandford (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Samuel Boxerman (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Gavin Cunningham (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Maria Carolina Duran (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Courtney Hikawa (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Trey Hilberg (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Joseph Zaleski (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Anastassiya Chechel (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Harold Forsyth (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Erika Lizardo (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Cecilia Galarreta (For: Republic of Peru)
- Representative
- Milagros Miranda (For: Republic of Peru)
- Expert
- Daniel Alegre (For: Republic of Peru)
- Expert
- Guillermo Garcia Montufar (For: Republic of Peru)
- Expert
- Brent Kaczmarek (For: Republic of Peru)
- Expert
- Isabel Kunsman (For: Republic of Peru)
- Expert
- Juan Pablo de la Puente (For: Republic of Peru)
International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes
- Arbitrator
- Gabrielle Kaufmann-Kohler
- Arbitrator
- Eduardo Zuleta
- Arbitrator
- Raul Emilio Vinuesa
- Tribunal secretary
- Alicia Martin Blanco
Other
- Witness
- Jorge Barragan
- Witness
- Dany Chumbes
- Witness
- Guillermo Cock
- Witness
- Edwin Benavente
- Witness
- Maria Elena Cordova
- Witness
- Ruth Fernandez
- Witness
- Ana Maria Hoyle
- Witness
- Elda Juarez
- Witness
- David de Lambarri
- Witness
- Guillermo Malaga
- Witness
- Nelson Manrique