Arbitral Digest

Matter

Alicia Grace and others v. United Mexican States (ICSID Case No. UNCT/18/4)

Alicia Grace and other investors' NAFTA dispute with Mexico concerning Oro Negro's oil-rig contracts, related investment losses, and Ontario proceedings on the award.

  • Investor-state arbitration
  • Setting aside arbitral awards
  • Jurisdiction and arbitration agreements
  • UNCITRAL Model Law
  • Cross-border litigation
Case no.
UNCT/18/4
Industry type
Mining and quarrying
Applicable rules
1976 UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules

Procedural record

  1. 25 March 2019Arbitration

    25 March 2019Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 1

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal established the procedural framework and calendar for the arbitration.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    11 days later · 11 days

  2. 5 April 2019Arbitration

    5 April 2019Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 2 on Amicus Curiae and Non-Disputing Party Participation

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal issued directions governing non-disputing party and amicus curiae participation.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    21 days later · 21 days

  3. 26 April 2019Arbitration

    26 April 2019Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 3 on Confidentiality

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal established the confidentiality and transparency procedure for the arbitration.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    1 month and 29 days later · 59 days

  4. 24 June 2019Arbitration

    24 June 2019Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 4 on the Ad Hoc Group of Bondholders' Application for Leave to Intervene

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    By majority, the Tribunal refused the applicants permission to file a submission and refused access to the parties' pleadings and evidence.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    1 month and 14 days later · 44 days

  5. 7 August 2019Arbitration

    7 August 2019Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 5 on the Procedural Calendar

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal set the procedural calendar and attached an updated calendar.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    4 months and 12 days later · 134 days

  6. 19 December 2019Arbitration

    19 December 2019Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 6

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal denied the requested measure in part and ordered the Respondent to cooperate with the conduct of the arbitration as specified in the order.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    7 months and 30 days later · 243 days

  7. 18 August 2020Arbitration

    18 August 2020Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 7

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal ruled on the procedural requests recorded in the order and directed applicable redactions and procedural steps.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    1 month and 21 days later · 52 days

  8. 9 October 2020Arbitration

    9 October 2020Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 8

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal decided the parties' document-production requests, including requests concerning financial information and confidential material.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    1 month and 2 days later · 33 days

  9. 11 November 2020Arbitration

    11 November 2020Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 9

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal maintained or confirmed the relevant decisions in Procedural Order No. 8, with the modifications and extensions stated in the order.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    4 months and 5 days later · 125 days

  10. 16 March 2021Arbitration

    16 March 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 10

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal issued directions concerning protective orders and the handling of documents obtained under them.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    1 month and 27 days later · 58 days

  11. 13 May 2021Arbitration

    13 May 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 11

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal accepted the Respondent's request and ordered the Claimants to produce documents obtained under the protective orders by 2 June 2021.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    14 days later · 14 days

  12. 27 May 2021Arbitration

    27 May 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 12

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal ordered that the Reply Memorial be published with the redactions proposed in the order.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    19 days later · 19 days

  13. 15 June 2021Arbitration

    15 June 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 13

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal granted the Respondent a two-week extension to file its Rejoinder.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    6 days later · 6 days

  14. 21 June 2021Arbitration

    21 June 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 14

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal granted a further one-week extension for the Respondent's filing.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    1 month and 14 days later · 44 days

  15. 4 August 2021Arbitration

    4 August 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 15

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal rejected the Respondent's request and maintained the procedural calendar established by Procedural Order No. 14.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    30 days later · 30 days

  16. 3 September 2021Arbitration

    3 September 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 16

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal rejected the Claimants' request.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    6 days later · 6 days

  17. 9 September 2021Arbitration

    9 September 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 17

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal decided the parties' requests for protection of information as set out in the order and its annexes.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    14 days later · 14 days

  18. 23 September 2021Arbitration

    23 September 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 18

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal rejected the Respondent's request to exclude Mr. Yanus from testifying and directed that he be called directly as a witness of the Tribunal.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    29 days later · 29 days

  19. 22 October 2021Arbitration

    22 October 2021Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 19

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal rejected the Claimants' request to strike Exhibit CR-36 and set directions for the hearing.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    3 months and 27 days later · 119 days

  20. 18 February 2022Arbitration

    18 February 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 20

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal directed that the hearing would take place in person in Washington, D.C., with remote participation for persons justifiably unable to attend.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    14 days later · 14 days

  21. 4 March 2022Arbitration

    4 March 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 21

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal rejected the Claimants' request to submit a third expert report on damages quantification.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    21 days later · 21 days

  22. 25 March 2022Arbitration

    25 March 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 22

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal ruled on remote participation, witness examination, and the production and admission of additional documents.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes
  23. 25 March 2022Arbitration

    25 March 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 23

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal issued directions for organizing the hearing at ICSID's facilities in Washington, D.C.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    13 days later · 13 days

  24. 7 April 2022Arbitration

    7 April 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 24

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal granted the Respondent leave to submit the additional documents specified in the order.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    5 days later · 5 days

  25. 12 April 2022Arbitration

    12 April 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 25

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal decided the parties' requests concerning remote participation in the hearing.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    1 day later · 1 days

  26. 13 April 2022Arbitration

    13 April 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 26

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal ruled on the Respondent's request to add new documentary evidence to the record.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    5 days later · 5 days

  27. 18 April 2022Arbitration

    18 April 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 27

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal rejected the Respondent's request that Mr. Trevino's two witness statements remain on the record.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    5 months and 2 days later · 155 days

  28. 20 September 2022Arbitration

    20 September 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 28

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal issued procedural directions concerning the post-hearing phase.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    2 months and 1 day later · 62 days

  29. 21 November 2022Arbitration

    21 November 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 29

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal ruled on the parties' proposed redactions to their Post-Hearing Briefs and directed submission of redacted versions.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    28 days later · 28 days

  30. 19 December 2022Arbitration

    19 December 2022Arbitration

    Procedural Order No. 30

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal rejected the Claimants' request to submit additional evidence into the record.

    Participants

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    1 year and 8 months later · 609 days

  31. 19 August 2024Arbitration

    19 August 2024Arbitration

    Final Award

    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes

    Decision summary
    The Tribunal unanimously found that it lacked jurisdiction over all of the Claimants' claims and dismissed them in their entirety. Claimants were allocated 75% of the fixed tribunal and ICSID costs, Respondent 25%, each Party was to bear its own fees and expenses, and Claimants were ordered to pay Respondent USD 397,619.3 for the expended portion of Respondent's advances to ICSID.

    Participants

    United Mexican States
    International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes
    Arbitrator
    Diego P. Fernandez Arroyo
    Arbitrator
    Andres Jana Linetzky
    Arbitrator
    Gabriel Bottini

    Authorities cited

    3
    • North American Free Trade Agreement
      treaty
    • UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules (1976) (UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules adopted 15 December 1976)
      rules
    • Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, 1969
      convention

    2 years, 1 month and 16 days later · 777 days

  32. 5 October 2026Canada

    5 October 2026Canada

    Decision of the Court of Appeal for Ontario in the case M57184 (COA-26-CV-0614) dated 5 October 2026

    Court of Appeal for Ontario

    Case no.
    M57184 (COA-26-CV-0614)
    Decision summary
    The Court of Appeal quashed Mexico's appeal from the Superior Court of Justice decision setting aside the jurisdictional award, holding that section 11 of the International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017 bars an appeal from that decision; it did not address the bias issue and awarded the moving parties $20,000 in costs.

    Participants

    Application
    Motion to quash appeal — Granted
    Alicia Grace
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Ampex Retirement Master Trust
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Apple Oaks Partners, LLC
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Cambria Ventures, LLC
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Axis Holding
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Clue and F. 305952
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Carolyn Grace Baring
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Diana Grace Beard
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Floradale Partners, LLC
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Frederick Grace
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Frederick J. Warren Ira
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Gary Olson
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Genevieve T. Irwin
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Gerald L. Parsky
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Gerald L. Parsky IRA
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    John N. Irwin III
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Axis Holding and F. 30592
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Nicholas Grace
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Oliver Grace III
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    ON5 Investments, LLC
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Rainbow Fund, L.P.
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Robert M. Witt
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Robert M. Witt IRA
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Vista Pros, LLC
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Virginia Grace
    Representative
    Emily Sherkey (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    Representative
    Natasha Williams (For: Alicia Grace · Ampex Retirement Master Trust · Apple Oaks Partners, LLC · Brentwood Associates Private Equity Profit Sharing Plan · Cambria Ventures, LLC · The Estate of Carlos Williamson-Nasi in its own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding · Clue and F. 305952 · Carolyn Grace Baring · Diana Grace Beard · Floradale Partners, LLC · Frederick Grace · Frederick J. Warren Ira · Gary Olson · Genevieve T. Irwin · Genevieve T. Irwin 2002 Trust · Gerald L. Parsky · Gerald L. Parsky IRA · John N. Irwin III · Jose Antonio Cañedo-White in his own right and on behalf of Axis Services · Axis Holding and F. 30592 · Nicholas Grace · Oliver Grace III · ON5 Investments, LLC · Rainbow Fund, L.P. · Robert M. Witt · Robert M. Witt IRA · Vista Pros, LLC · Virginia Grace)
    The United Mexican States
    Representative
    Benedict S. Wray (For: The United Mexican States)
    Representative
    Michelle Folinas (For: The United Mexican States)
    Court of Appeal for Ontario
    Judge
    Grant Huscroft
    Judge
    Gary T. Trotter
    Judge
    Darla A. Wilson

    Authorities cited

    3
    • International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017 (Ontario) (S.O. 2017, c. 2, Sched. 5)
      statute
    • UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration
      model law
    • North American Free Trade Agreement, 17 December 1992, Can. T.S. 1994 No. 2
      treaty

Matter record

Report a correction

Alicia Grace and others v. United Mexican States (ICSID Case No. UNCT/18/4) · Matter