Matter
[J] SpA v [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A and [H] SGPS S.A (Paris Court of Appeal RG 24/07876)
- 25 September 2023Arbitration
25 September 2023Arbitration
Final arbitral award dated 25 September 2023
International Court of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce
- Decision summary
- The sole arbitrator declared the claim concerning a €67,959,000 penalty inadmissible, found the tribunal competent over [H] and found breaches by [R] [N] of the Master Franchise Agreement. The award ordered [R] [N] to stop specified uses of Midas experience and pay [J] €419,000, rejected the remaining contractual and customer-indemnity claims, allocated arbitration and defence costs, and ordered provisional enforcement.
Supporting details
1 authority · 5 participants[J] SpA
[R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A
[H] SGPS S.A
International Court of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce
- Institutional administrator
- International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- [X] [W]
3 months and 22 days later · 113 days
- 16 January 2024Arbitration
16 January 2024Arbitration
Decision and addendum on fees dated 16 January 2024
International Court of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce
- Decision summary
- The sole arbitrator rejected [J]'s correction and interpretation requests, allocated the additional ICC costs of USD 12,500 to [J], ordered [J] to reimburse €14,141.25 in reasonable defence costs, and rejected all other requests.
Supporting details
4 participants[J] SpA
[R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A
[H] SGPS S.A
International Court of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- [X] [W]
1 year, 10 months and 25 days later · 695 days
- 11 December 2025France
11 December 2025France
Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal in the case RG 24/07876 dated 11 December 2025
Paris Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The Paris Court of Appeal rejected [J] SpA's requests to revoke the closure order and reopen the proceedings, declared inadmissible its total and partial annulment requests concerning the 16 January 2024 ICC decision and fees addendum, and declared inadmissible its damages claim against [R] [N] and [H]. It dismissed the remaining claims, dismissed the respondents' damages claims, ordered [J] to pay the costs, and ordered [J] to pay each respondent €30,000 under Article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.
Supporting details
4 authorities · 17 participants[J] SpA
- Representative
- Audrey LAZIMI (For: [J] SpA)
- Representative
- SELEURL AUDREY LAZIMI AVOCAT (For: [J] SpA)
- Representative
- Benoît LE BARS (For: [J] SpA)
- Representative
- LAZAREFFLEBARSEURL (For: [J] SpA)
[R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A
- Representative
- Luca DE MARIA (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- SELARL PELLERIN - DE MARIA - GUERRE (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- Pierre DUPREY (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- Daria ASTAKHOVA (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- Willia ZOUAOUI (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- AUDIT-DUPREY-FEKL (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
[H] SGPS S.A
- Representative
- Luca DE MARIA (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- SELARL PELLERIN - DE MARIA - GUERRE (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- Pierre DUPREY (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- Daria ASTAKHOVA (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- Willia ZOUAOUI (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
- Representative
- AUDIT-DUPREY-FEKL (For: [R] [N] - Reparacao de Automoveis S.A · [H] SGPS S.A)
Paris Court of Appeal
- Judge
- Daniel BARLOW
- Judge
- Jacques LE VAILLANT
- Judge
- Joanna GHORAYEB
- Court clerk
- Najma EL FARISSI
- Date not availableFrance
Date not availableFrance
Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal rejecting the challenge to the final award dated 25 September 2023
Paris Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The Paris Court of Appeal rejected [J] SpA's annulment challenge to the final arbitral award dated 25 September 2023.