Matter
STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR v TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.
ICC arbitration between Ukraine's State Road Agency (Ukravtodor) and Todini concerning works contracts, with partial awards and related French and Ukrainian court proceedings.
Aliases: State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor) v Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A. · State Agency of Motor Roads of Ukraine v Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A. · Italian Construction Company Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A. v State Road Agency of Ukraine
Procedural record
- 26 June 2018France
26 June 2018France
First Partial Award
International Chamber of Commerce
- Decision summary
- Recognised and enforced in Ukraine in case 824/235/2018.
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews
7 months and 4 days later · 218 days
- 30 January 2019France
30 January 2019France
Second Partial Award
International Chamber of Commerce
- Decision summary
- Recognised and enforced in Ukraine in case 824/260/2018.
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews
4 months later · 120 days
- 30 May 2019Ukraine
30 May 2019Ukraine
Judgment of the Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court in the case 824/235/2018 dated 30 May 2019
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
- Decision summary
- The court granted Todini's appeal, cancelled the stay of the Ukrainian recognition and enforcement proceedings, and remanded the matter to the Kyiv Court of Appeal.
Participants
Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.
- Representative
- Markiian Kliuchkovskyi (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
- Representative
- Oleksandr Volkov (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor)
- Representative
- Maksym Lesyk (For: State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor))
- Representative
- Oleksandr Luhovskyi (For: State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor))
- Representative
- Viktor Martsynyshyn (For: State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor))
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
5 months and 28 days later · 181 days
- 27 November 2019France
27 November 2019France
Third Partial Award
International Chamber of Commerce
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews
2 months and 10 days later · 71 days
- 6 February 2020Ukraine
6 February 2020Ukraine
Judgment of the Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court in the case 824/235/2018 dated 6 February 2020
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
- Decision summary
- The court dismissed Ukravtodor's appeal and upheld recognition and permission for enforcement in Ukraine of the First Partial Award dated 26 June 2018.
Participants
Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.
- Representative
- Markiian Kliuchkovskyi (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
- Representative
- Oleksandr Volkov (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor)
- Representative
- Maksym Lesyk (For: State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor))
- Representative
- Oleksandr Luhovskyi (For: State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor))
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
1 day later · 1 days
- 7 February 2020France
7 February 2020France
Addendum to the Third Partial Award
International Chamber of Commerce
- Decision summary
- Supplement to the Third Partial Award.
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews
3 months and 21 days later · 111 days
- 28 May 2020Ukraine
28 May 2020Ukraine
Judgment of the Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court in the case 824/260/2018 dated 28 May 2020
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
- Decision summary
- The court dismissed Ukravtodor's appeal and upheld recognition and permission for enforcement in Ukraine of the Second Partial Award dated 30 January 2019.
Participants
Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.
- Representative
- Markiian Kliuchkovskyi (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
- Representative
- Oleksandr Volkov (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor)
- Representative
- Maksym Lesyk (For: State Road Agency of Ukraine (Ukravtodor))
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
8 days later · 8 days
- 5 June 2020France
5 June 2020France
Fourth Partial Award
International Chamber of Commerce
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews
6 months and 5 days later · 188 days
- 10 December 2020Ukraine
10 December 2020Ukraine
Judgment of the Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court in the case 824/235/2018 dated 10 December 2020
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
- Decision summary
- The court dismissed Ukravtodor's appeal and upheld the Kyiv Court of Appeal order of 15 June 2020 concerning clarification of the First Partial Award enforcement order.
Participants
Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.
- Representative
- Oleksandr Volkov (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
- Representative
- Oleksandr Sintsov (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
2 months and 27 days later · 89 days
- 9 March 2021France
9 March 2021France
Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal in the case RG 18/21326 dated 9 March 2021
Paris Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The Paris Court of Appeal rejected all inadmissibility objections and the application to set aside the First Partial Award dated 26 June 2018, and ordered Ukravtodor to pay EUR 50,000 under Article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure and the costs.
Participants
STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR
- Representative
- Luca DE MARIA (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
- Representative
- Benjamin SIINO (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
- Representative
- François BORDES (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.
- Representative
- Matthieu BOCCON GIBOD (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
- Representative
- Lucille MONTAUT (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
Paris Court of Appeal
- Judge
- François ANCEL
- Judge
- Fabienne SCHALLER
- Judge
- Laure ALDEBERT
- Court clerk
- Clémentine GLEMET
- 9 March 2021France
9 March 2021France
Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal in the case RG 19/04410 dated 9 March 2021
Paris Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The Paris Court of Appeal rejected all objections and the application to set aside the Second Partial Award dated 30 January 2019, and ordered Ukravtodor to pay EUR 50,000 under Article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure and the costs.
Participants
STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR
- Representative
- Luca DE MARIA (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
- Representative
- Benjamin SIINO (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
- Representative
- François BORDES (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.
- Representative
- Matthieu BOCCON GIBOD (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
- Representative
- Lucille MONTAUT (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
Paris Court of Appeal
- Judge
- François ANCEL
- Judge
- Fabienne SCHALLER
- Judge
- Laure ALDEBERT
- Court clerk
- Clémentine GLEMET
8 days later · 8 days
- 17 March 2021France
17 March 2021France
Fifth Partial Award
International Chamber of Commerce
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews
9 months and 18 days later · 293 days
- 4 January 2022France
4 January 2022France
Case-management order of the Paris Court of Appeal in the case RG 20/12921 dated 4 January 2022
Paris Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- Case-management order in French proceedings concerning the ICC arbitration.
- 4 January 2022France
4 January 2022France
Case-management order of the Paris Court of Appeal in the case RG 21/11372 dated 4 January 2022
Paris Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- Case-management order in French proceedings concerning the ICC arbitration.
6 months and 28 days later · 209 days
- 1 August 2022France
1 August 2022France
Seventh Partial Award
International Chamber of Commerce
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews
3 months and 7 days later · 99 days
- 8 November 2022France
8 November 2022France
Judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal in the case RG 22/00121 dated 8 November 2022
Paris Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The Paris Court of Appeal reformed the 4 January 2022 case-management order and stayed the annulment proceedings pending the Cour de cassation ruling on the appeals against the 9 March 2021 judgments.
Participants
STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR
- Representative
- Luca DE MARIA (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
- Representative
- Louise BOUVERY (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.
- Representative
- Matthieu BOCCON GIBOD (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
- Representative
- Christophe LAPP (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
- Representative
- Chiraz ABID (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
Paris Court of Appeal
- Judge
- Daniel BARLOW
- Judge
- Hélène FILLIOL
- Judge
- Fabienne SCHALLER
- Court clerk
- Najma EL FARISSI
- 8 November 2022France
8 November 2022France
Referral judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal in the case RG 21/11372 dated 8 November 2022
Paris Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- Referral judgment in French proceedings concerning the ICC arbitration.
29 days later · 29 days
- 7 December 2022France
7 December 2022France
Judgment of the Cour de cassation in joined appeal W 21-18.687 dated 7 December 2022
Cour de cassation
- Decision summary
- The Cour de cassation rejected the joined appeals against the Paris Court of Appeal judgments of 9 March 2021.
Participants
STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR
- Representative
- SARL Ortscheidt (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.
- Representative
- SARL Delvolvé et Trichet (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
Cour de cassation
- Judge
- M. CHAUVIN
- Judge
- Mme Guihal
- Judge
- M. Hascher
- Court clerk
- Mme Vignes
- 7 December 2022France
7 December 2022France
Judgment of the Cour de cassation in joined appeal X 21-18.688 dated 7 December 2022
Cour de cassation
- Decision summary
- The Cour de cassation rejected the joined appeals against the Paris Court of Appeal judgments of 9 March 2021.
Participants
STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR
- Representative
- SARL Ortscheidt (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.
- Representative
- SARL Delvolvé et Trichet (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
Cour de cassation
- Judge
- M. CHAUVIN
- Judge
- Mme Guihal
- Judge
- M. Hascher
- Court clerk
- Mme Vignes
2 years, 4 months and 29 days later · 881 days
- 6 May 2025Ukraine
6 May 2025Ukraine
Procedural order of the Kyiv Court of Appeal in the case 824/235/2018 dated 6 May 2025
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The court allowed the State Treasury's representative to participate by video conference in the duplicate-writ application.
Participants
State Treasury of Ukraine
- Representative
- Tetiana Tymofieieva (For: State Treasury of Ukraine)
Kyiv Court of Appeal
7 days later · 7 days
- 13 May 2025Ukraine
13 May 2025Ukraine
Procedural order of the Kyiv Court of Appeal in the case 824/235/2018 dated 13 May 2025
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The court allowed video-conference participation for the relevant representatives in the duplicate-writ application.
Participants
State Treasury of Ukraine
- Representative
- Tetiana Tymofieieva (For: State Treasury of Ukraine)
Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.
- Representative
- Veronika Hodlevska (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
State Agency for Restoration and Infrastructure Development of Ukraine
- Representative
- Nataliia Kozhushko (For: State Agency for Restoration and Infrastructure Development of Ukraine)
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- 13 May 2025Ukraine
13 May 2025Ukraine
Procedural order of the Kyiv Court of Appeal in the case 824/235/2018 dated 13 May 2025
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The court allowed video-conference participation for the relevant representatives in the duplicate-writ application.
Participants
State Treasury of Ukraine
- Representative
- Tetiana Tymofieieva (For: State Treasury of Ukraine)
Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.
- Representative
- Veronika Hodlevska (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
State Agency for Restoration and Infrastructure Development of Ukraine
- Representative
- Nataliia Kozhushko (For: State Agency for Restoration and Infrastructure Development of Ukraine)
Kyiv Court of Appeal
9 days later · 9 days
- 22 May 2025Ukraine
22 May 2025Ukraine
Order of the Kyiv Court of Appeal in the case 824/235/2018 dated 22 May 2025
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The court granted the State Treasury's application and ordered duplicate enforcement writs for the First Partial Award amounts and UAH 881 court costs.
Participants
State Treasury of Ukraine
- Representative
- Tetiana Tymofieieva (For: State Treasury of Ukraine)
- Representative
- V. Palchyk (For: State Treasury of Ukraine)
Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.
- Representative
- Veronika Hodlevska (For: Todini Costruzioni Generali S.p.A.)
State Agency for Restoration and Infrastructure Development of Ukraine
- Representative
- Nataliia Kozhushko (For: State Agency for Restoration and Infrastructure Development of Ukraine)
Kyiv Court of Appeal
1 month and 18 days later · 49 days
- 10 July 2025France
10 July 2025France
Incident order of the Paris Court of Appeal in the case RG 22/17589 dated 10 July 2025
Paris Court of Appeal
- Decision summary
- The Paris Court of Appeal held that the case-management judge lacked subject-matter jurisdiction over Todini's inadmissibility objection, dismissed the abuse-of-process damages claim, and ordered Todini to pay costs and EUR 6,000 under Article 700.
Participants
STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR
- Representative
- Luca DE MARIA (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
- Representative
- Jennifer YOUNAN (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
- Representative
- Emmanuel JACOMY (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
- Representative
- Erwan POISSON (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
- Representative
- Louise BOUVERY (For: STATE ROAD AGENCY OF UKRAINE - UKRAVTODOR)
TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.
- Representative
- Matthieu BOCCON GIBOD (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
- Representative
- François MULLER (For: TODINI COSTRUZIONI GENERALI S.P.A.)
Paris Court of Appeal
- Judge
- Jacques LE VAILLANT
- Court clerk
- Najma EL FARISSI
- Date not availableFrance
Date not availableFrance
Eighth Partial Award
International Chamber of Commerce
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews
- Date not availableFrance
Date not availableFrance
Final Award
International Chamber of Commerce
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews
- Date not availableFrance
Date not availableFrance
Sixth Partial Award
International Chamber of Commerce
Participants
International Chamber of Commerce
- Arbitrator
- Sir Anthony Edwards-Stuart
- Arbitrator
- Richard Fernyhough
- Arbitrator
- Duncan Matthews