Matter
Supreme Court of Ukraine case 824/11/26 (12 June 2026)
An anonymized commercial arbitration concerned delayed delivery, contractual penalties, and replacement goods, followed by Ukrainian proceedings concerning the seat and challenge of the award.
Procedural record
- 21 November 2025Ukraine
21 November 2025Ukraine
Arbitral Award of the International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Ukrainian Chamber of Commerce and Industry in case 452/2024 dated 21 November 2025
International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Ukrainian Chamber of Commerce and Industry
- Decision summary
- The arbitral tribunal ordered Anonymized Party 2 to pay Anonymized Party 1 redacted penalties for delayed delivery, late correction of defects, and breach of quality terms, reimburse the arbitration fee, and deliver replacement goods under the contract.
Participants
Anonymized Party 1
Anonymized Party 2
International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Ukrainian Chamber of Commerce and Industry
3 months and 20 days later · 112 days
- 13 March 2026Ukraine
13 March 2026Ukraine
Ruling of the Kyiv Court of Appeal in the case 824/7/26 dated 13 March 2026
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Citation
- 824/7/26
- Decision summary
- The Kyiv Court of Appeal deemed Anonymized Party 2's application to set aside the arbitral award in case 452/2024 not filed and returned it because the applicant failed to cure the identified deficiencies within the prescribed time.
Participants
- Application
- Application to set aside the arbitral award — Returned as deemed not filed
Anonymized Party 2
- Representative
- OSOBA_1 (For: Anonymized Party 2)
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Judge
- S. M. Verlanov
7 days later · 7 days
- 20 March 2026Ukraine
20 March 2026Ukraine
Ruling of the Kyiv Court of Appeal in the case 824/11/26 dated 20 March 2026
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Citation
- 824/11/26
- Decision summary
- The Kyiv Court of Appeal opened proceedings on Anonymized Party 2's application to set aside the arbitral award of the International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Ukrainian Chamber of Commerce and Industry dated 21 November 2025 in case 452/2024, invited the Ministry of Defence of Ukraine to submit objections and evidence by 3 April 2026, and scheduled the application for hearing on 6 April 2026.
Participants
Anonymized Party 2
- Representative
- OSOBA_1 (For: Anonymized Party 2)
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Judge
- L. P. Sushko
17 days later · 17 days
- 6 April 2026Ukraine
6 April 2026Ukraine
Ruling of the Kyiv Court of Appeal in the case 824/11/26 dated 6 April 2026
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Citation
- 824/11/26
- Decision summary
- The Kyiv Court of Appeal transferred to the Lviv Court of Appeal for territorial jurisdiction the materials concerning Anonymized Party 2's application to set aside the arbitral award in case 452/2024, because the parties had agreed that the seat of arbitration was Lviv, Ukraine.
Participants
Anonymized Party 1
- Representative
- OSOBA_2 (For: Anonymized Party 1)
Anonymized Party 2
- Representative
- OSOBA_1 (For: Anonymized Party 2)
Kyiv Court of Appeal
- Judge
- L. P. Sushko
- Court Secretary
- I. V. Yanchuk
28 days later · 28 days
- 4 May 2026Ukraine
4 May 2026Ukraine
Ruling of the Supreme Court of Ukraine in the case 824/11/26 dated 4 May 2026
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
- Citation
- 824/11/26
- Decision summary
- The Supreme Court opened appellate proceedings on Anonymized Party 1's appeal against the Kyiv Court of Appeal's transfer of the proceedings concerning Anonymized Party 2's application to set aside the arbitral award in case 452/2024, requested the case file, and invited a written response within ten days of service.
Participants
Anonymized Party 1
- Representative
- OSOBA_2 (For: Anonymized Party 1)
Anonymized Party 2
- Representative
- OSOBA_1 (For: Anonymized Party 2)
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
- Judge
- Mykhailo Yu. Titov
- Judge
- A. Yu. Zaitsev
- Judge
- Yevhen V. Korotenko
1 month and 4 days later · 35 days
- 8 June 2026Ukraine
8 June 2026Ukraine
Ruling of the Supreme Court of Ukraine in the case 824/11/26 dated 8 June 2026
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
- Citation
- 824/11/26
- Decision summary
- The Supreme Court completed the preparatory steps for the appeal concerning Anonymized Party 2's application to set aside the arbitral award in case 452/2024 and scheduled an open hearing for 2 July 2026 on Anonymized Party 1's appeal against the transfer of the case from the Kyiv Court of Appeal to the Lviv Court of Appeal.
Participants
Anonymized Party 1
- Representative
- OSOBA_2 (For: Anonymized Party 1)
Anonymized Party 2
- Representative
- OSOBA_1 (For: Anonymized Party 2)
Supreme Court of Ukraine, Civil Cassation Court
- Judge
- Yevhen V. Korotenko
- Judge
- I. A. Vorobiova
- Judge
- A. Yu. Zaitsev